Analytical Rubric to Assess Historical and Social Science Thinking
1
Incomplete
 2
In Progress
3
Fluent
 4
Exemplary

Relating Historical Events, People, Eras

  • does not use comparison and contrast appropriately
  • does not draw conclusions
  • does not relate past to present
  • limited use of comparison and contrast
  • draws some conclusions
  • sometimes relates past to present 
  • uses comparison and contrast appropriately
  • draws a conclusion
  • relates past to present
  • demonstrates extensive use of comparison and contrast
  • draws insightful conclusions
Analyzing Cause and Effect 
  • does not sequence events
  • does not tell how events relate
  • does not analyze cause and effect
  • puts few events in a sequence
  • tells how some events relate to each other
  • analyzes some causes and effects
  • puts events in a sequence
  • tells how events relate to each other
  • analyzes multiple causes and effects
  • shows extensive understanding of relationships
  • provides insight into cause and effect
Using Multiple Perspectives 
  • does not examine issues from other points of view
  • does not analyze, summarize, and compare views
  • examines some issues from other points of view
  • analyzes, summarizes, and compares few different points of view
  • examines issues from other points of view
  • analyzes, summarizes, and compares different points of view
  • demonstrates a clear and extensive understanding of multiple perspectives
Defending a Position
  • cannot take a point of view
  • does not form logical arguments
  • does not support arguments with evidence
  • does not show knowledge of other points of view
  • researches a topic and arrives at a limited interpretation
  • forms some logical arguments
  • supports arguments with limited evidence
  • shows some knowledge of other points of view
  • researches a topic and arrives at an interpretation
  • can take a point of view
  • forms a logical argument
  • supports arguments with evidence
  • shows knowledge of other points of view
  • conducts extensive research
  • arguments or statements are supported with ample fact and detail
  • clearly understands all points of view
Interpreting Data
  •  cannot put data in own words, or explain meaning
  • cannot relate data to context
  • does not evaluate reliability of data
  • does not interpret data
  • does not use appropriate tools for interpretation
  • can put some data in own words
  • can relate data to a limited context
  • limited evaluation of reliability of data
  • forms limited interpretation of the data
  • uses some tools for interpretation
  • can put data in own words, explains meaning
  • can relate data to context
  • evaluates reliability of data
  • forms an interpretation of data
  • uses appropriate tools for interpretation
  • can clearly relate data to its context and other contexts
  • interprets data in an insightful manner
  • extensively uses graphs, charts, etc., to interpret and analyze data

Analytical rubric developed by Heidi Dettwiller from California Department of Education materials